The Christian Fantasy

LarsIn his essay, “On Fairy Stories,” J. R. R. Tolkien, the greatest modern Christian fantasist, drove what should have been a fatal stake (perhaps of mistletoe) through the heart of the accusation that fantastic stories are “just escapism”: “Why should a man be scorned, if, finding himself in prison, he tries to get out and go home? Or if, when he cannot do so, he thinks and talks about other topics than jailers and prison-walls?”

The accusation itself helps to explain why fantasy gets so little respect in our time (there’s another reason; I’ll get to it later). For the growing number of people who believe there is no world outside our present prison, any talk of sunshine, meadows, and mountains has to be plain denial, a way of fooling ourselves about our true situation. Materialists who write about Magic are likely (though not certain) to write about it badly. They shouldn’t try it, for the same reason a Christian shouldn’t try writing porn. It’s hard to do well something you despise. This may also explain much of the truly bad fantasy that gets published today. The charge of escapism might be a sort of self-generating rot.

In past generations, fantasy actually enjoyed pretty high status. What are Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey but works of fantasy? Dante’s Divine Comedy is a Christian fantasy in verse. So are Spenser’s Faerie Queen and Milton’s Paradise Lost and Paradise Regained. Shakespeare wrote fantasy (“A Midsummer Night’s Dream” among others), and Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress is an allegorical fantasy. Only the coming of the Enlightenment locked the door and turned the key on a literary form that had been plenty good enough for the Greeks and Romans

But there’s a second reason why fantasy gets no respect. We (here I’m speaking as a fantasy writer) have earned it. I’ll make a confession here. I don’t read much fantasy, and I read almost no Christian fantasy. I’ve been burned too many times. You buy a book, hoping to experience over again the joys great fantasy can provide (for me, the Mines of Moria, the Ride of the Rohirrim, and the resurrection of Aslan provided the greatest moments of joy I’ve ever experienced in literature), and what do you get? Wannabees. Wannabee Tolkiens, wannabee Lewises, wannabee (christened) George R. R. Martins.

This springs (I think) from a basic misconception about fantasy—one that shows how few Tolkien and Lewis fans have learned anything from their role models.

The misconception goes like this—“Fantasy is just made-up stuff. It’s like dreams. Whatever you fantasize is good enough.”

No, no, no, no.

If that were true, fantasy would deserve its critical blacklisting. The fact that fantasy isn’t (generally) bound to our workaday world makes it harder to do, not easier. It’s like playing a musical instrument. Most are easy to play . . . badly. Playing them well requires time and work.

Who’s writing good Christian fantasy today? I was afraid you’d ask. As I said, I don’t know the field as well as I should. Walter Wangerin Jr. wrote one of the best fantasies of any kind I’ve ever read, The Book of the Dun Cow, an amazing animal story that I promise will break your heart and put it together again. Stephen Lawhead is an excellent writer who has never (in my opinion) soared to the heights he’s capable of. Jeffrey Overstreet may be the best. His Auralia Thread novels sometimes take narrative turns I’m not crazy about, but the books are wonderfully written and they’re like nothing else you’ve ever read. And the one quality that’s most often lacking in Christian fantasy, besides plain wordsmithing, is originality.

Beyond that I haven’t got much.

And the reason, as stated above, is that fantasy is hard.

Look at the masters. Tolkien and Lewis weren’t only fanboys (though they certainly were that by the standards of their time). They were scholars, and scholars at the top level. Tolkien’s work was the fruit of decades, not only of storytelling, but of mastering his source material. All those rich passages in The Lord of the Rings, and in the collateral works, spring from his profound knowledge of European languages, a subject he may have known better than anyone who ever lived. It all started with inventing a language. The story grew from the grammar. The depth of the man’s scholarship is like a rock foundation under every sentence he wrote, every name he bestowed on a character. The books feel real because he knew what he was writing about.

Even though it only existed in his imagination.

Trying to write “like Tolkien” without some degree of his scholarship is a project doomed to fail.

Or to state it in blues men’s terms, “You gotta pay your dues.”

How do you produce good fantasy (I won’t say great fantasy; that’s beyond my expertise)?

First of all, remember this truth—e-books make it possible to publish your own book. That does not earn you the right to expect anyone else to read it.

Writing is a craft, like shoemaking. I don’t care how sincerely the guy who made my shoes loves shoes. The main thing I want from him is expertise, the practiced knowledge of how to put together a shoe that fits, won’t give me blisters, and lasts a while. Your sincerity may please God, but He also says, “Whatever you do, work at it with all your heart, as working for the Lord, not for men” (Colossians 3:23, NIV). It’s possible you may be a prodigy, a literary Mozart capable of amazing the world right out of the gate. But probably not.

I’m kind of sad for young writers today. You have much less opportunity to enjoy a benefit we old-timers had in abundance—rejection. Oh, we hated those editors who sent us their mimeographed rejection slips—“We’re sorry, but your work does not meet our present needs.” We railed at them as Philistines who hated and feared new ideas, guarding the gates of the Inner Chamber for the benefit of their rich, famous cronies.

But oh, what a joy it was to get that first acceptance letter! It didn’t come easy, that letter. One story at a time, rejection after rejection, we learned to prune and tighten our prose, and that first acceptance was a sign that we’d finally earned our way inside the Gates (only, finally, to look down with pitying contempt on those amateurs who cluttered the desks of “our” editors with their puerile, formless scribblings).

Such editors hardly exist anymore. Today’s writers, so often self-published (I’m not speaking in contempt; I’m self-publishing now myself), lack that thick wall to chop through, that sparring partner to toughen them up. I read so many self-published books now that leave me saying, “This writer has a good story and interesting characters. All he needs is a real editor to tell him to cut out the dead wood.”

The second thing missing in most fantasy today is . . . what will I call it? Organic knowledge. My field is mostly historical fantasy, concentrating on the Viking Age. I’ve been researching that period for more than fifty years. More recently I’ve become a reenactor, which gives me the opportunity to get more hands-on experience. I’ve drunk mead in a Viking hall, slept in a Viking tent, and helped row a Viking boat. I know how the clothes feel and what Vikings smelled like (smoke—the houses were full of it).

I also grew up on a working farm, an unending source of sensory memories. These things help, not only in getting the details right, but in adding a quality that’s impossible to quantify: the resonance of authenticity. People tell me my books have it (I have no way of telling).

Also, I speak Norwegian. I wish it were Old Norse, but even the modern language allows me to play with words in sentences, recasting them in a foreign voice that sounds Viking to English speakers.

You, being a child of a wired, digital world, will have a harder time getting a sense of preindustrial life, unless you grew up on a commune or something.

I’m not saying your preparation has to be like mine, or like Tolkien’s. I’m just saying that good fantasy needs to be built on a profound knowledge of something beyond fantasy stories. Your house must be built on rock, not sand.

There’s no royal road. It will take years, not months. You’ll need to produce your quota of dreck before the good stuff starts to come. But if you pay your dues, you can create a fantasy that will glorify Christ, not only in message but in craftsmanship.


Lars Walker is the author of several published fantasy novels, including the recently released e-book Hailstone Mountain, the latest in his series, “The Saga of Erling Skjalgsson.” He also blogs at Brandywine Books.

  • Pingback: QotD: Why your fantasy novel is crap edition | Res Studiorum et Ludorum()

  • Pingback: Lars Walker on Christian Fantasy()

  • Pingback: First Links — 3.21.13 » First Thoughts | A First Things Blog()

  • Pingback: First Links — 3.21.13 - CATHOLIC FEAST - Sync your Soul()

  • Jairo Namnún

    Thank you for such a well written article about a subject so overlooked. God bless you and I will make sure to read some of your work.

  • Timothy Wood

    Excellent article. In the list of decent Christian fantasy, I feel Chris Walley’s The Lamb Among the Stars series deserves wider readership. Strictly speaking, the far-future, post-millennial sci-fi may not count as fantasy, but I enjoyed the exploration of sin and redemption in a very novel form.

  • Pingback: Writers Need Rejection » First Thoughts | A First Things Blog()

  • Pingback: Writers Need Rejection - CATHOLIC FEAST - Sync your Soul()

  • Ryan Szrama

    One could always turn to Mormon authors… I find Brandon Sanderson’s books to be among the most engaging, inventive, and carefully crafted stories I read today. Have read ’em all and am working through a reread right now.

    • G. Fisher

      The Mormons have been steeped in fantasy from their start.

    • Guest

      Yes, I have noticed that. After all, the whole thing got started with a very bad attempt to write a “sequel” to the Bible — one of the very first bad works of fanfiction. :-)

      • My Name is Private

        I deeply beg to differ. I am a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and I cannot deny that, after fervent prayer to God, The Book of Mormon is factually true. Obviously you see otherwise, but the testimony I have of it has grown to such a strong state that I would die before denying the truthfulness of my gospel.

  • Pingback: Why I Want to Be George R. R. Martin’s Neighbor()

  • Chuck Beem

    Completely agree on The Book of the Dun Cow. Fantastic book.

  • Ryan Szrama

    Agreed! Can’t believe that comment didn’t come to mind first. My wife and I love the series.

  • Pingback: Speculative Faith Blog — Lars Walker Critiques ‘The Christian Fantasy’()

  • Pingback: Speculative Faith: Lars Walker Critiques ‘The Christian Fantasy’()

  • Pingback: Laudable Linkage | Stray Thoughts()

  • Pingback: Speculative Faith Blog — Lars Walker: Beyond ‘Wannabe’ Fantasy()

  • Bryn Williams

    It can’t be a coincidence that I read this post as I have been forming a preliminary story for a novel on Pontius Pilate. I’ve never written an original story myself but I’m pouring through information about the times and how I need to fill the gaps. I find myself fascinated by Pilate and his question to Christ.
    On another note, I find it heretical that nobody mentioned G.K. Chesterton. I’ve read his “The Ball and the Cross” as well as “The Man Who Was Thursday: A Nightmare” and cannot recommend them enough.

    • Robert Denethon

      I love Chesterton! Haven’t read “The Ball and the Cross” but “The Man Who Was Thursday” is brilliant, as are his Father Brown series (the recent BBC TV show just didn’t capture the essence of Father Brown’s detecting method, which is the primacy of intuition over rationality at apprehending truth) – also his non fiction book “Orthodoxy” is one of my favourites, and is one of the books that inspired CS Lewis to become a Christian, I believe.

      Chesterton’s method of merging a sort of modern style with a solid Christian message was a big inspiration for the books I’ve written (A Feather on the Breath of Ellulianaen, Gryphonomicon series, Steam Submarine Zelf) Which I have, essentially, self published. (Referring to Lars’ post now)
      I gave up on the system after an editor in a publishing house kept my book on the desk for 9 months, expressing interest, then finally declined to publish it, I suspect, partly to keep it off the market while she was promoting another author with a similar book.
      I’m working on some things now that I might send out to some publishers, but self-publishing is working fine for me at the moment.
      I do agree that it takes a lot of work to be a writer. On the other hand, even CS Lewis wrote a few flops before he wrote a great book (a lot of poetry, and Pilgrim’s Regress, which essentially did not do well at the time) And the opportunity to learn on the job is not really there any more.

  • Pingback: Speculative Faith Blog — Who Reads Christian Speculative Fiction?()

  • Pingback: Terrible Tuesday: Houseguest Edition « Oddly Said()

  • Pingback: FRC Blog » The Social Conservative Review: March 28, 2013()

  • Jamie Schultz Foley

    I couldn’t agree more. It drives me crazy how Christian works in general seem to be re-hashes of other stories, or completely lacking in any real creativity or depth.

    I mean, the Bible is full of action and, honestly, violence… so why can’t we write an awesome fight scene? And why can’t we be real and ask the deep questions? Jesus is courageous to the max!

    The deep lack of great Christian fantasy (excluding Tolkien and Lewis and a select few others, of course) drove me to spend 10 years developing my own fantasy world, Alani, and begin writing my own books, which are dedicated to having a fast-paced plot, excellent characters, and a 100% unique adventure that leaves you wanting more.

    I just had my first book published a few weeks ago, called Sentinel, on Amazon Kindle and paperback will be available in a few weeks. If any lovers of top-notch fantasy are out there, check out Sentinel here: It’s my goal that it’ll not only be one awesome ride of a read, but that it will bring glory to Christ and positively impact just one person for him.

    Christians, let’s get to work… and reclaim fantasy like Tolkien and Lewis did!

  • Susan Bowman

    Elizabeth Anne Stengl’s Goldstone series is beautifully written (her first book is the least interesting, but it was her first book) deeply moving and surprises with profound moments. I like the way she folds time. I haven’t found anything else as satisfying in this genre. I’ve read the complete series and recommend ya’ll giving them a try. I am mostly disappointed with Christian fiction, but she has renewed my hope.